Nobody Told You This
About CanadaThe honest guide for newcomers

Article

From Drama Teacher to Economic Hitman: The Full Story of Trudeau and Carney

A drama teacher promised a better life. A banker who was never elected now runs the country. Here is what happened, with the dates and the numbers.

From Drama Teacher to Economic Hitman: The Full Story of Trudeau and Carney

Watch the 60-second video version on YouTube →

You are about to spend years of savings to move to Canada. Before you do, you should know who runs the country, how they got there, and what the numbers look like now.

This is the story in full: a drama teacher who promised a better life, a friendship with Fidel Castro that is real, emergency powers used against truckers, a resignation, and a banker who became prime minister without ever facing a voter. Every date and number below is checked against a public source. Where the story is opinion, it is labelled as opinion.

The face that started it all

They say Justin Trudeau looks like Fidel Castro. Put the two men side by side and decide for yourself. The resemblance is real enough that millions of people have shared the photos online. But the rumour that Castro was Justin Trudeau's father is not true, and the dates prove it.

Justin Trudeau was born on December 25, 1971. His parents, Pierre and Margaret Trudeau, made their first trip to Cuba together in January 1976, when Justin was already four years old. There is no record of Margaret Trudeau visiting Cuba before 1976. The baby in the famous 1976 photo of Castro holding an infant is not Justin at all. It is his younger brother Michel, who was four months old at the time. Justin did not even go on that trip.

Justin Trudeau and a young Fidel Castro, side by side
Justin Trudeau and a young Fidel Castro, side by side. The resemblance is real. The paternity rumour is not: the dates rule it out. SOURCE: The Free Library

What is real is the friendship. Pierre Trudeau was the first leader of a NATO country to visit Cuba, in January 1976, at the height of the Cold War. He and Castro became genuine friends. When Pierre Trudeau died in September 2000, Castro flew to Montreal for the state funeral and served as an honorary pallbearer. That is the true story, and it is strange enough without the rumour.

A drama teacher wins Canada, then COVID changes it

Before politics, Justin Trudeau was a teacher in Vancouver. He taught drama, French and math at West Point Grey Academy and Sir Winston Churchill Secondary School. In 2015, after nearly ten years of Conservative government under Stephen Harper, Canadians wanted change. Trudeau promised a better life, and on October 19, 2015, the Liberals won 184 of 338 seats with 39.5% of the vote. He was sworn in as prime minister on November 4, 2015, at 43 years old.

He would stay in power for more than nine years. Then COVID came, and Canada changed.

During the pandemic, the federal government brought in vaccine mandates for federal workers and for travel. In Quebec, the rules went further than almost anywhere else. On January 6, 2022, Health Minister Christian Dubรฉ announced that from January 18, 2022, you needed a vaccine passport just to enter a provincial liquor store (SAQ) or cannabis store (SQDC). No passport, no bottle. The rule lasted about a month; it was lifted for those stores on February 16, 2022.

Then came the protest that defined Trudeau's time in office. In late January 2022, truckers drove to Ottawa to protest the vaccine mandate for cross-border truck drivers, which had taken effect on January 15. Trucks blocked streets in the capital for weeks. On February 14, 2022, Trudeau invoked the Emergencies Act, declaring a public order emergency. It was the first time the Act had ever been used since it became law in 1988. Banks were told to freeze the accounts of protesters and donors without a court order. The powers were revoked nine days later, on February 23.

Trucks block a street in Ottawa during the February 2022 convoy protest
Trucks block a street in Ottawa during the February 2022 convoy protest. SOURCE: Foundation for Freedom Online

The courts have since had their say, and it is a mixed record that a newcomer should know. A public inquiry led by Justice Paul Rouleau reported in February 2023 that the high threshold for invoking the Act was met. But the Federal Court ruled in January 2024 that the invocation was unreasonable, beyond the government's legal power, and a breach of Charter rights to free expression and against unreasonable search and seizure. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld that ruling on January 16, 2026. In October 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada agreed to hear the government's appeal. The final word has not been spoken.

The fall

By late 2024, Trudeau's government was in trouble. Housing costs and the cost of living had risen for years. On December 16, 2024, Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland resigned from cabinet hours before she was due to present the fall economic statement. On January 6, 2025, Trudeau announced he would resign as prime minister and Liberal leader once the party chose his successor.

By then he had also become a target of mockery abroad. US President Donald Trump took to calling him "Governor Trudeau" and joked that Canada would become the 51st state. Elon Musk replied to Trudeau on X in January 2025: "Girl, you're not the governor of Canada anymore, so doesn't matter what you say." On March 10, 2025, Trudeau walked out of the House of Commons carrying his chair, tongue out, as departing MPs are allowed to take their chairs with them. That was the end of his nine years in power.

The handoff: who is Mark Carney?

But before he left, power passed to a man Trudeau himself had brought in. In September 2024, Trudeau named Mark Carney as a special adviser and chair of the Liberal Party's Task Force on Economic Growth. Six months later, Carney won the Liberal leadership on March 9, 2025, with 85.9% of the vote. On March 14, 2025, he was sworn in as Canada's 24th prime minister.

Carney was the first prime minister in Canadian history who had never held elected office before taking the job. No Canadian had ever voted for him. He was not even a member of Parliament. That changed only at the election that followed.

Justin Trudeau and Mark Carney at the Liberal leadership handover in March 2025
Justin Trudeau and Mark Carney at the Liberal leadership handover in March 2025. SOURCE: TruthBacked

Carney spent 13 years at the investment bank Goldman Sachs, working in London, Tokyo, New York and Toronto. He became Governor of the Bank of Canada in February 2008, just as the global financial crisis hit, and served until June 2013. Then he became Governor of the Bank of England, from July 2013 to March 2020, the first non-Briton ever to run it in its more than 300-year history.

His record in Britain is mixed, and the numbers need care. Business investment in Britain rose just 1.25% in the years after the Brexit referendum, while in the rest of the G7 it grew 12% on average. Those are Carney's own words, from his report to the UK Parliament's Treasury Committee in February 2020. Growth slowed through his last years there, reaching 1.3% in 2019, the weakest year since 2012 on current data.

Before the Brexit referendum, on May 12, 2016, Carney warned that a vote to leave the European Union could possibly include a technical recession. The recession never came. In the first full quarter after the vote, the British economy grew 0.6%. That is a fair criticism to make, and it is also fair to say what he actually did: he warned of a risk, he did not promise a recession.

After London, Carney moved to Brookfield Asset Management as vice-chair, took a role at Bloomberg, and served as the United Nations Special Envoy on Climate Action and Finance. Then, in September 2024, Trudeau made him his economic adviser. Six months later he was prime minister.

The election: Canada votes with a pencil

On April 28, 2025, Canadians went to vote. Canada still votes on paper ballots, counted by hand. At every polling station, voters are given a black-lead pencil to mark their ballot. Elections Canada says pencils are used because pens can dry up or leak and spoil a ballot, and that a voter may bring a pen instead. Ballots are counted by pairs of paid workers in front of witnesses. The video asks the question; the official answer is that the system is built on paper, seals, serial numbers and witnesses, not on trust in the pencil.

Carney's Liberals won 169 of 343 seats, with 43.76% of the vote, three short of the 172 needed for a majority. The Conservatives won 144 seats with 41.31%. Turnout was 69.5%, the highest since 1993. Carney himself was elected as the member of Parliament for Nepean, Ontario. The Liberals governed as a minority until April 2026, when floor crossings and by-election wins gave them a majority.

Canada now: the numbers, and the verdict

Budget 2026, tabled on November 5, 2026, projects a federal deficit of $62.3 billion for 2026โ€“27, about 1.8% of the economy. The government projects the deficit will still be $52.9 billion in 2030โ€“31. These are projections, not final results, but they are the government's own numbers.

$62.3 billionprojected federal deficit for 2026โ€“27, Budget 2026SOURCE: Department of Finance Canada, Budget 2026

At the same time, the federal government's own count found more than 65,000 people homeless on a single night in 2025, across 75 communities, 59% more than in 2020โ€“2022. Carney has promised to put Canada on a path to end homelessness within 10 years, with $11.2 billion in Budget 2026. Ten years means ten more winters for people sleeping outside in a country where winter temperatures fall far below freezing.

Parliament Hill in winter
Parliament Hill in winter. Budget 2026 projects a $62.3 billion deficit for 2026โ€“27. SOURCE: Department of Finance Canada, Budget 2026

And while homelessness rose at home, Canada committed more than $26 billion in assistance to Ukraine since 2022, including over $14 billion in direct financial support and $8.5 billion in military assistance, according to the government's own response to Parliament in September 2026. Remus Bogdan's argument is that this money could have ended homelessness in Canada. For scale: the Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated in May 2024 that reaching the federal homelessness target would take an extra $3.5 billion a year. Readers can do their own math on what $26 billion means against that figure.

65,000+people homeless on a single night in 2025, up 59% from 2020โ€“2022SOURCE: Everyone Counts 2025, Government of Canada

Here is where fact ends and opinion begins, and the line matters. Remus Bogdan's verdict is that Mark Carney is an "economic hitman": a banker who never built anything, never worked for a paycheque, moving from bank to bank and country to country, spending money that is not his. The phrase comes from John Perkins' book "Confessions of an Economic Hit Man". It is a conclusion drawn from Carney's career path, not a proven fact, and it is presented here as the author's verdict, not as a finding of any court or inquiry.

A banker who never built anything is running Canada. That is the author's verdict. The facts above are yours to judge it by.

What is fact is the path itself: Goldman Sachs, two central banks, Brookfield, Bloomberg, the United Nations, then adviser, then party leader, then prime minister, all without facing a voter until the general election. What you make of that path is your decision.

If you are thinking of moving to Canada, this story is not a reason to stay home or to come. It is a reason to decide with your eyes open. The country you are shown in recruitment videos is real in some ways and incomplete in others. Check the numbers yourself at the sources below. Then decide.

Check before you believe any video, including ours

Dates beat rumours. Justin Trudeau was born in 1971; his parents' first Cuba trip was 1976. Court rulings beat slogans: the Emergencies Act story is still before the Supreme Court. And a projection is not a result: the $62.3 billion deficit is what Budget 2026 forecasts, not what the year will finally show.

Sources

Read the free chapter first

One full chapter of the book โ€” free, no card, no commitment. Read it, then decide for yourself.

Read the free chapter Get the book โ€” CA$3.99 crypto / CA$4.49 card

This price is for the first 1,000 readers โ€” after that, it goes up.

Book + audiobook in one purchase. Paid once.

Planning your move?

A few services that help with the practical side of coming to Canada:

This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. See all partners and the full disclosure.

← All articles